Random Image

essenswcemeterypolice09

Recent Updates

The 90th Anniversary...
I attend many memorial events as a participant-observer....
mhatlie - Mon Nov 17, 10:53
I agree it is not a surprise...
There was _some_ attention paid to WW1 in the press,...
mhatlie - Sun Nov 16, 15:27
no time for remembering
I have to say, I don’t find the lack of interest...
Michael Prince (anonymous) - Sun Nov 16, 09:46
New marker for deserters...
Last July, the Tübingen city council voted to...
mhatlie - Fri Nov 14, 12:22
Dial-a-Memory
Munich, the one-time „capitol of the movement“...
KMPRINCE - Mon Oct 6, 09:51

New Sites...



The Sites of Memory webpage continues to grow. I have now added five new pages with memorials from the German city of Muehlacker/Enz and downtown Stuttgart. The new sites include cemeteries for the fallen of both world wars as well as two Franco-Prussian War markers. There are now 44 pages with over 50 memorials and a total of 386 photos.

The monument to the Franco-Prussian War (shown in image) is an example of a relic with virtually no current relevance occupying prime real estate. On the one hand, nobody pays any attention to it, other than the teenagers who sit around on it on summer evenings and drink beer and smoke. I don't even think tourists take much notice of it. It takes up a full city block only two or three blocks off of the prime shopping street in Stuttgart, right off of Schlossplatz, where all the tourists come. On purely rational, economic grounds, it should probably be destroyed or moved to some park somewhere and the space used for something else. On the other hand, the city is obviously still spending money on its maintenance. The statue, pedastal and obelisks are all in very good condition. The obelisks appear to have been recently rennovated at no small cost. The inscriptions listing the battles and events of the war are clearly readable in gold script.

Michael Prince (anonymous) - Thu Jan 10, 11:23

comment on monument to Franco-Prussian War

On "purely rational, economic grounds," it's possible a great many memorials and monuments might be removed or demolished. But I'm not sure that a dearth of public appreciation should be a primary reason for doing so. If that were the case, then some of history's important events may no longer find any representation in the public sphere.

This does raise a serious question, however, having to do with the relevance of specific memorials and at what point they may cease to serve a useful purpose. Most often, memorials are removed or destroyed when changes in political circumstances alter the memory culture they were meant to represent. The most obvious recent examples would be the numerous Marx and Lenin statues and other socialist sculpture that disappeared from various locations thoughout Eastern Europe after the end of the Cold War.

Should expiration dates be applied to public monuments and, if so, how are we to determine what those should be? Should removal be approved by simple majority vote? Or does respect for minority interests require that, in some (perhaps many) cases, monuments be maintained, even when the bulk of popular opinion wishes them removed? It may be easier, in a certain sense, to determine when a monument is no longer appropriate. But is it as easy to decide when one is no longer relevant?

There seems to be much room for opinion and discussion here.

logo

Sites of Memory

Welcome

This blog grew out of the sites-of-memory.de project. It features impressions and analysis of past and present memorial culture.

If you would like to be an author for this blog, see our call for contributors.

The blog logo is a photo of a statue at the soldiers' "Brethren Cemetery" in Riga, Latvia.

Aministrator Contact

M. Hatlie
Im Feuerhägle 1
72072 Tübingen
Germany
Cell: +49-163-1341718
e-mail

Disclaimer

The authors are solely responsible for what they write in this blog. We do not accept responsibility for the content behind any of the links posted here. We make every effort to check them, but their content can change. The owners of the webpages linked to are solely responsible for the content of those webpages.

Status

Online for 1113 days
Last update: Tue Nov 18, 22:11

Search

 

About this blog
Armenian Genocide
Central Europe
Estonia
Europe
Falkland Islands
German memorial culture
Great Britain
Holocaust Denial
India
Iran
Italy
Latvia
Los Angeles
Memory Studies
Odds and Ends
... more
Profil
Logout
Subscribe Weblog